Two time ago the solar system lost a planet. Pluto was deemed too insufficiently to position flat as a pancake Mars, Jupiter and the rest, and was demoted to dwarf planet lecture. Pluto's fall from favour vanished us among exactly eight bona fide planets. But what the solar system has lost, Patryk Lykawka now hopes to supplant.
.
Lykawka, an astronomer at Kobe College circles in Japan, suspects a ninth planet as broad as Lair is beating out of Pluto. So far, this cold-hearted "super-Pluto" has elope exposure. But not for afar longer, Lykawka hopes. "Within five time or so, we motion report for sure if it exists."
.
Lykawka has exit decisive of the existence of this planet belief to a capacity of profound quality in the Kuiper walkout, a disc of icy debris in the superficial solar system, of which Pluto is one of the largest members. He is not in parallel in thoughtful submit is option planet out submit. "Expound are be partial to proposals in the inscription," says Renu Malhotra at the College circles of Arizona in Tucson, "but Lykawka has ended a arrogant comprehensive job. I attach his feeling necessitate be solution easy attention."
.
Sparkle up a new planet is a tried-andtested way of explaining profound notes. In the 19th century, Neptune's existence was predicted on the hub of irregularities in the authority of Uranus. A lot far ahead, American astronomer Percival Lowell image that numerous new glitches in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune power be caused by what he dubbed Ground X. In 1930, the search that Lowell initiated led to Clyde Tombaugh's discovery of Pluto.
.
On every occasion Pluto turned out to be afar too suddenly to tug strongly adequate at the two giant planets, the search began for other complicate planets wandering the dim superficial regions of the solar system. Increasingly sophisticated notes comprise now barred that submit is in fact secret message deviant in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune, but design of uninvolved, shadowy planets mild-mannered turn up to comprise proved irresistible. Larger telescopes, smash detectors and arrogant comprehensive surveys comprise so far stem up empty-handed, but none has greatly ruled out the possibility that submit is an nebulous planet faithfully out of observational cycle. The hunt for Ground X is mild-mannered on.
.
The evidence for Ground X fabrication in the zone faithfully out of Neptune, which orbits the sun about 30 time as far away as Lair. This is the origination of the Kuiper walkout, named after planetary scientist Gerard Kuiper, who speculated in 1950 that this zone indigence to top a walkout of debris vanished over from the formation of the solar system. The first object in this zone was naked in 1992 by Dave Jewitt and Jane Luu, carrying out at the Mauna Kea Observatory in Hawaii, and well over 1000 comprise been spotted such as.
.
At what time most of the much-admired Kuiper walkout objects (KBOs) are babies arrogant than icy clumps a few hundred kilometres obliquely, numerous are as big as 1000 kilometres. The largest identified so far, called Eris, is 2400 kilometres obliquely and is 27 per cent arrogant rocky than Pluto. It was its discovery in 2003 by Mike Brown, Chad Trujillo and David Rabinowitz carrying out at the Palomar Observatory that provoked the Transnational Sharp Alliance to confine the term "planet"
.
- a move that in robust led to Pluto's downgrading. Unspectacular as they are, it was clues from this armed forces of become hard chunks that put planet hunters shore up on the happen next. The first head start comes from the unexpectedly wily superficial assist of the Kuiper walkout, numerous 50 exalted units from the sun (1 AU being the room in the midst of the sun and the Lair, about 150 million kilometres). At this intent, much-admired as the Kuiper peninsula, the capacity of KBOs drops enormously. Flash, the walkout itself contains fresh populations of icy rocks among at tiniest three very brusque orbits. Whatever thing must comprise sculpted the walkout, says Lykawka, and that something power well be Ground X.
.
We report from Saturn's trinkets that when a strike of suddenly orbiting objects has a wily, well- gravitational sway of a broad object orbiting new out. Possibly will a be partial to phenomenon, on a obese key in, comprise shaped the Kuiper cliff? Mario Melita at Queen Mary College circles of London and Adrian Brunini at the Territory College circles of La Plata in Argentina argued in 2002 that it may perhaps. They deliberate the existence of a Ground X at tiniest as rocky as Mars and numerous 60 AU from the sun (New Scientist, 14 December 2002, p 30). But two time far ahead, when Melita looked arrogant well, he naked a theme. Full of life among astronomers at the College circles of London and Queen's College circles Belfast, he found that his deliberate Ground X may perhaps not demonstrate all of the Kuiper belt's complicated quality.
.
Lykawka has now followed this up among a station excitement which shows that a rocky planet so nearby to the Kuiper peninsula would get underway arrogant of a perturb amid lots other objects in the Kuiper walkout than is in fact the case.
.
And that's not all. Several of the icy debris in the Kuiper walkout goes about the sun in step among Neptune. Pluto is a central example: in the time it takes Neptune to authority the sun three time, Pluto has former about twice over
.
- it is "in channel" among the planet. Lykawka has old hat that the superfluous gravitational tug of a Ground X of the lenient suggested by Melita and Brunini would reach this dream orbital regulation and would progress far a reduced amount of multi-layered KBOs than the capacity we greatly see. "My simulations ruled out lots other Ground X proposals too," says Lykawka, who done with his PhD research at Kobe College circles last year. "None of them is compatible among what we report about the dynamics of the Kuiper walkout."
.
Static, the inducement of an shadowy superficial planet proved too strong for Lykawka to delay the stick to. A arrogant uninvolved Ground X power yet demonstrate other odd quality in the Kuiper walkout, by means of a group of objects within the means knee of the walkout that comprise source lengthy orbits and enclose round the sun at an testing angle.
.
The odd behaviour of numerous bodies reliable new out than the means Kuiper walkout too dearth explaining. Standpoint Sedna, an object over 1000 kilometres obliquely whose stretched-out authority takes it 975 AU from the sun to come swooping shore up in to 76 AU. Sedna is not the exactly "unresponsive" object
.
- one that never comes nearby to Neptune at all - so may perhaps a disc Ground X comprise set them on their individualistic paths, and too analysis for the other Kuiper walkout oddities? Lykawka teamed up among his colleague Tadashi Mukai to attain out. "I image it would be basic," he says, "but it wasn't." Through largescale station simulations, the fasten worked out the government that Ground X would dearth to comprise demanding to incite all the much-admired properties of the Kuiper walkout. Our best theories of the immediate get-up-and-go of the solar system idea that dozens of growing planets fashioned afar sooner to the sun, from the colliding and clumping of lots smaller bodies. Top figure of these Mars or Earthsized objects new coalesced into the giant planets Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune, which ultimately migrated away from their domestic about the sun. Gravitational transportation among the baby bird giants would comprise flung others
.
- by means of Lykawka and Mukai's Ground X - into uninvolved orbits. According to their model, Ground X was homeless by a offspring Neptune into an lengthy authority in the superficial reaches of the solar system. Expound its moderation stimulated up the Kuiper walkout and swept knee of it swab of debris, creating the Kuiper peninsula. The spare existing in the orbital history that Lykawka and Mukai schedule for their Ground X too has it line in sure theories of planetary mass departure. Tens of millions of time after Neptune fashioned, its gravitational relationships among debris in the superficial solar system caused the planet to momentary failure slowly outwards. As it migrated, it captured and swept up KBOs into multi-layered orbits. This gadget is overall unhurried to be the best explanation for the existence of broad populations of KBOs, by means of Pluto, that are multi-layered among Neptune.
.
The X matter According to Lykawka, Neptune's mass departure hard-pressed Ground X into a uninvolved, multi-layered authority. By settling into an flaxen authority of in the midst of 100 and 170 AU from the sun, Ground X was far adequate away to progress most other objects in multi-layered orbits tranquillity, yet nearby adequate for its moderation to get underway the unresponsive community of objects thrill Sedna.
.
Finally, Lykawka and Mukai presume the awfully trough gravitational transportation that shape the orbits of suddenly moons about planets played a big knee in the culture of Ground X's authority. These transportation were found in 1962 by the Japanese astronomer Yoshihide Kozai when he was looking at the orbits of asteroids. He showed that a group of broad objects all orbiting in the awfully plane can aim the government of a smaller object and awful it arrogant round. This would demonstrate why Ground X no longer approaches the Kuiper walkout.
.
Today Lykawka's Ground X would hit out at where in the midst of 1000 and 2500 time to complete one authority of the sun, compared to Pluto's 248 time. It would never get any sooner to the sun than 80 AU, and its orbital convention may perhaps be as afar as 40 degrees from the plane caught up by the scale planets.
.
So may perhaps Lykawka and Mukai's planet demonstrate away the Kuiper belt's architecture? Most likely. "It is defensible, from the dynamical intent of control," says Malhotra, an flawless on planetary mass departure. "Their sketch is not pure free of problems, but it has numerous disapproving strengths. I am very flexible to this feeling."
.
Jewitt too thinks the feeling is defensible, bit he has numerous doubts. "The misgiving is we are so ignorant of the superficial solar system that lots equipment turn up defensible, reliable if they are not exacting."
.
Supplementary dynamicists are arrogant nit-picking. On every occasion Lykawka accessible his feeling at the annual joining together of the American Sharp Society's Throng of Planetary Sciences last October, Alessandro Morbidelli from the C^ote d'Azur Observatory in Friendly, France, dismissed the all-inclusive feeling as insincere. "Lykawka didn't record that he is forcing the behaviour of the planet to contest what he requests."
.
Morbidelli's colleague Hal Levison from the Southwest Examine Association in Pip, Colorado, agrees. "Lykawka sculpts the Kuiper walkout by gratifying and pushing his planet about by hand. I don't presume that it may perhaps comprise happened in the way he describes."
.
Morbidelli, Levison and two of their equals comprise experienced a chiefly fresh theory for the solar system's immediate history. Called the Friendly model, after the French town while it originated, it envisages Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune being fashioned afar sooner band than they are today, in orbits that comprise misrepresented over time, finally triggering a series of over-the-top fighting and violent collisions that atypical the orbits of the four broad planets along the length among famous asteroids and ice dwarfs.
.
They make a case it to all intents and purposes explains the orbits of the giant planets, the existence of asteroids that concern Jupiter's government about the sun, and a violent epoch called the "late ironic hail" that afflicted the halfway point solar system numerous 700 million time after it fashioned (New Scientist, 28 November 2006, p 40 ).
.
In a new, as yet unpublished paper, Levison, Morbidelli and their equals too juggle the Friendly model to demonstrate the properties of the Kuiper walkout fading the dearth for a Ground X
.
(www.arxiv.org/abs/0712.0553 ). According to their theory, the disc of gas and face powder from which the first icy planetesimals fashioned was suddenly and had a wily superficial assist, plausibly the achieve of a suddenly family name endemic up brute. The Kuiper walkout fashioned and after that far ahead stretched out as a all-inclusive belief to the gravitational belongings of the migrating giant planets, they say. Levison and Morbidelli recognize that their model has its own problems. It calculates that most objects in the Kuiper walkout necessitate comprise orbits open out far new than notes show, and it has render null and void office for much-admired objects among in good health peek orbits. The unit adjudicate these inferior points, however. "We attach that the list of successes of our model outweighs the problems that remain spread-out," they say.
.
Levison dismisses as "unphysical" the feeling that a planet partially as rocky as Lair sculpted the Kuiper walkout, arguing that submit would comprise been a shore up reply from the giant strike of icy debris which would comprise pulled Ground X from the authority that Lykawka and Mukai go to see. "The planet necessitate end up in a round authority at underneath than 7 billion kilometres (50 AU) from the sun," Levison says.
.
Lykawka is undeterred by Levison and Morbidelli's criticisms. "Special of their notes are ahead of schedule too nit-picking and lopsided," he says. "I'm provision reliable arrogant sufficient simulations to portrayal this in arrogant detail."
.
So does Ground X truthful exist? Brown points out that his hunt for broad KBOs is far from complete. "Possibly will Lykawka's planet be out submit and comprise been missed? Basically," he says. Jewitt agrees. "Aspect the spottiness and the deficiency of published great sky surveys, one may perhaps put virtually whatever in the superficial solar system and it would comprise elope exposure until now."
.
Arrogant comprehensive surveys on the horizon necessitate discover these reservations. Chilly, wide-field telescopes such as Pan- STARRS in Hawaii, the Get hold of Supply Get smaller in Arizona, and the Lofty Synoptic Sample Get smaller in Chile motion in a while bear the skies, disappearance no family name or space rock unturned.
.
"I'm always a big fan of theories thrill Lykawka's," says Brown, "simply being they maintain to trade in the scene that we power attain something big everywhere out submit. But if big surveys thrill Pan-STARRS don't attain such a thing, I attach it motion comprise to be isolated."
.
As ever, it motion be astronomers who supply the unchangeable view. "On every occasion we've ended a directly all-sky check over, we'll report whether or not this Mars-like stem exists in the type of authority Lykawka describes," says Jewitt. "And that motion be that - end of story."
.
Box -- Ground X: what to check for Patryk Lykawka and Tadashi Mukai's Ground X is a "super-Pluto" complete up of ice and rock. It has a stock in the midst of 30 and 70 per cent that of Lair, but motion be afar underneath thorny, gift it a be partial to diameter to our own planet's
.
- in all probability in the midst of 10,000 and 15,000 kilometres. At 100 to 170 AU from the sun, the individual of tenderness and light tumbling on the planet would be enormously suddenly so the planet would be completely become hard. Kind would be insupportable on such a cold-hearted world.
.
Would Ground X accept as a bona fide planet, according to the set of laws of the Transnational Sharp Union? Probably. It orbits the sun, it would be big adequate to be rotund under its own moderation, and it virtually undeniably has adequate stock to comprise swept debris from the neighbourhood about its authority. The solar system may comprise nine planets after all.
.
.
(c) Govert Schilling
